374 Colgate Rd

East Jewett, NY 12424

3 Bedrooms   •   2 Bathrooms

Schedule Visit

374 Colgate Rd
East Jewett, NY

Property Information



Undeniably charming farmhouse built in 1890 sits on 3 beautiful acres next to an old apple orchard with views of the mountains and the East Kill Creek flowing from Colgate Lake (arguably one of the most beautiful lakes in the area) and right through the back yard.

Step through the lovely covered porch and into the first floor of the home which features a cozy living room with built-in day bed in a bright, window-filled nook, separate formal dining room, updated country kitchen, one bedroom, and updated bathroom with walk-in shower. At the back of the house, an airy and bright family room has windows that look onto the views of the mountains, a freestanding wood stove that gives you all the warm and fuzzy feels in the colder months, and doors that open out to the back yard with its rolling creek. The top floor includes two bedrooms and a recently renovated and bright full bathroom with soaking tub in its own large, light-filled room and a stackable washer/dryer.

In the heart of the Catskills in East Jewett, this home is just minutes to swimming and kayaking on Colgate Lake, 10-15 minutes to shops and restaurants in Tannersville, Prospect Restaurant and Bar at Scribner’s Catskill Lodge, skiing in Hunter and Windham, hiking in nearby wild forests including Kaaterskill Falls, and less than 2 hours to NYC.

Listed by Danny Romero and Megan Brenn-White, Real Estate Agents, The Upstate Real Estate Team of Keller Williams Realty Hudson Valley North. 

Note: Buyer to confirm all pertinent information including square footage, property taxes, short term rental restrictions, etc. Seller is working with the town to correct bed/bath count on county report. Contract is subject to right of first refusal to be exercised within 30 days of accepted offer. Due to uncertain nature of appraisals and the unique character of the property, the seller strongly prefers cash and, if not, prefers financed offers using local lenders and including an appraisal floor of $350,000.



Year Built

Living Space
1,274 sq ft

Lot Size
3 acres

Property Type
Single Family


Property Tax

Included Amenities

Apple Orchard
Mountain Views
Creek Views
East Kill Creek
Colgate Lake
Covered Porch
Updated Kitchen
Freestanding Wood Stove
Renovated Bathroom
Soaker Tub
Minutes to Swimming
Minutes to Kayaking
10-15 min to Dining & Shops
Spring Fed Well

Video Tour


The Upstate Real Estate Team Listing Assistant
Listing Agent   •   The Upstate Real Estate Team of Keller Williams Realty Hudson Valley North

The Upstate Real Estate Team Listing Assistant

  Cell: (845) 262-6110

Contact us at listings@upstate-realestate.com or 845-262-6110 for any initial questions or to schedule a showing!

Interested in selling your home? We'd love to hear more! Fill out our seller form to get a home valuation. 

Need a buyer's agent? Fill out our new Buyer Questionnaire to get the ball rolling! 

Follow @upstatecurious for life and properties in the Catskills and Hudson Valley and be sure to download our new app Upstate Curious | If you're new to the home buying process, don't miss our video's on YouTube, like Timeline for Buying a House Upstate to help you get started!

Request Info

Ask Questions or Schedule a Visit

More Listings